888.407.0714

New York Life vs Protective Life Insurance

New York Life and Protective are two solid life insurance companies. Rest assured you can't make a bad choice if you have narrowed it down to New York Life and Protective. See our side by side comparison below to see how these two companies stack up. We have included financial ratings, current leadership, assets, and premium in force for both New York Life and Protective.
  • YEAR FOUNDED
    1907
  • CURRENT CEO
    John D. Johns
  • AVAILABLE
    All 50 States
  • ADDRESS
    111 Congresional Blvd., Suite 500 Carmel, IN 46032
  • TOP AWARDS

    2010 Optimas Award from Workforce Management Magazine

  • PROS
    • Financially sound.
    • Competitive, comprehensive rates.
    • Flexible health guidelines.
  • CONS
    • Approval can take awhile.
    • Low tolerance for smoking.
  • YEAR FOUNDED
    1845
  • CURRENT CEO
    Theodore Alexander Mathas
  • AVAILABLE
    49 States
  • ADDRESS
    51 Madison Avenue New York, NY 10010 United States
  • TOP AWARDS

    Fortune Magazine’s List of World’s Most Admired Companies For 2017

    Forbes America’s Best Large Employers 2017

    BEQ Pride LGBTQ Business Equality Excellence Award

  • PROS
    • Great option for Seniors
    • Flexible Terms
    • High Death Benefits
  • CONS
    • Lackluster website
    • Poor customer resources
    • No Online Quoting

Compare Other Options

1st place trophy
1st

Health IQ is a unique life insurance brokerage that gets you special rates if you live an active lifestyle. If you exercise a few times per week, you can qualify for lower rates. Click below to get an accurate quote.

2nd place trophy
2nd

AIG, also know as American International Group, has been in business since 1919. AIG's strong financial rating, product selection and competitive pricing earns it the #2 spot.

3rd place trophy
3rd

Banner is a subsidiary of Legal & General, and have been in business since 1836. They hold an A+ financial rating and have some of the most competitive rates. This earns them the #3 spot.

SOURCE Protective New York Life
JD Power 774 4/5
BBB A+ A+
AM Best A+ A++
Moody's A1 Aaa
Fitch A+ AAA
Standard & Poor AA- AA+
Comdex Score 92 100
SOURCE Protective New York Life
Total Assets $75 Billion USD (2016) $303.182 billion
Life Insurance in Force $767.3 Billion $992.8 billion
Protective New York Life
Term Life InsuranceYearly Convertible Term
Whole Life InsuranceLevel Premium Convertible Term
Universal Life InsuranceWhole Life Insurance
Variable Universal Life InsuranceUniversal Life Insurance
Indexed Universal Life InsuranceVariable Universal Life Insurance
Survivorship Universal Life Insurance
Life Insurance for Children
Protective New York Life
Protective Custom Choice UL Yearly Convertible Term
Protective Advantage Choice ULLevel Premium Convertible Term
Protective Classic Choice TermWhole Life Insurance
Protective One Year Term Universal Life Insurance
ProClassic II Variable Universal Life Insurance
ProClassic Legacy
Protective Classic Choice Term
Investors Choice VUL
Strategic Objective VUL
Survivorship Term
Survior UL
Protective Whole Life
Protective New York Life
Accidental death benefit riderAccidental Death Benefit Rider
Accelerated death benefit riderChildren’s Insurance Rider
Waiver of premium riderChronic Care Rider
Disability income riderDisability Waiver of Premium Rider
Guaranteed insurability riderLiving Benefits Rider
Term insurance riderSpouse’s Paid-Up Insurance Purchase Option
Children’s term riderPolicy Purchase Option Rider
Jonathan Holloway
January 1, 1970
Jonathan is a licensed life insurance agent at NoExam.com that writes about insurance, personal finance, lifestyle, and sports. See our pages on term life insurance, life insurance rates and life insurance companies for more.
Disclaimer: We make every attempt to make sure our information is up to date, but since things change often it is best to double check the data. This review is an opinion. Clicking on links may result in NoExam.com being compensated.